Wow! So many
blockbuster trades today! The day got going early when Jon Lester and Jonny
Gomes were sent to the Oakland Athletics, but they got Yoenis Cespedes in
return! Then when everybody thought David Price would stay in Tampa, he ends up
being traded in a three-team deal.
What I find interesting
about this trade deadline is that over the past two days, lots of players were
dealt, but not many highly touted prospects moved as well. The only big
acquisition dealing with a lot of prospects was with the Marlins and Astros,
which I’ll talk about below. It just goes to show that some of these prospects
are too valuable to teams, and they like their futures. That, or they didn’t
have any big prospects to begin with.
In my mind, there are
five teams that made the biggest splash in the trade market this July: Boston,
Oakland, St. Louis, Detroit, and Tampa Bay. The Chicago Cubs also made a big
splash, but because their biggest acquisition occurred earlier in the month, so
instead of talking about old news, I’ll refrain from grading them.
Please
note that my grading takes in current success, future success, how teams benefit/suffer financially, etc.
Boston Red Sox: A-
The Red Sox made five
trades over the past two days, clearing up a lot of their expiring contracts
and grabbing some present and future talent. Plus, they grabbed players that
they can sign extensions to so that they are not competing with other players
in the offseasons.
Here’s who was traded
and where to:
Jon Lester- Athletics
Jonny Gomes – Athletics
John Lackey – Cardinals
Stephen Drew – Yankees
Andrew Miller – Red Sox
Felix Doubront – Cubs
And here’s who they got
out:
Yoenis Cespedes
(Athletics)
Joe Kelly (Cardinals)
Allen Craig (Cardinals)
Kelly Johnson (Yankees)
Eduardo Rodriguez
(Orioles)
Plus a
player-to-be-named-later from the Cubs. If you look at it, they only got one
prospect in Rodriguez. He was recently ranked as the third best prospect in
Baltimore’s farm system by MLB.com, and now 10th best for the Red
Sox.
Allen Craig was one of
the most dangerous hitters last year when he batted .315/.373/.457 and had a
batting average with RISP over .400, which was by far the best in baseball.
After getting injured and losing his touch in the clutch, Craig’s numbers have
regressed this year significantly. Personally, I think it’s more of a move to
get him a different scenery, and he will perform better at Fenway.
I find Joe Kelly a very
interesting piece. At 26 years old, Kelly has too battled with injuries this
year. Like Craig, however, he had a great season last year, both as a starter
and a reliever. Remember, this was the guy that started off the NLCS for the
Cards, getting a no-decision.
And how about grabbing
Cespedes? He’s already wowed fans with his arm this year, and now he’s going to a team where he can wow them with homers over the green monster. At 28, he’s
not the kind of guy who can hit for contact, but he has power that is rare
nowadays. Sign him an extension, and the Red Sox will have him for a long time.
The Red Sox did trade
lots of their pitching, but they have prospects Henry Owens and Allen Webster
that are ready to come up at any point now. It will look like a revamped
pitching rotation, but that’s nothing to be afraid of.
Now 12 games under
.500, the Red Sox are not contending anymore. But here’s what the first six in
their order will look like next season (as long as they’re healthy):
1.
Some leadoff hitter (Mookie Betts?
Jackie Bradley Jr.?)
2.
Dustin Pedroia
3.
David Ortiz
4.
Yoenis Cespedes
5.
Mike Napoli
6.
Xander Bogaerts
Add Craig into that mix
too, and that’s one scary lineup. So when Ortiz retires, they now have Cespedes
to take his place to hit some out.
Oakland Athletics:
?????
All of these trades
that Oakland has made will depend on one thing: a title. If they win it this
year, then all of the trades matter. If not, however, Billy Beane has some
explaining to do.
They have given up a
ton to get where they are now. Losing Cespedes and top prospect Addison Russell
is HUGE to their future success. But while many are still shaking their heads
about trading away Cespedes, remember that he is going to be a free agent soon,
and the Athletics won’t be able to afford him.
As for losing Russell,
well, I think Beane might regret that one.
Here’s an interesting
stat, though. The Athletics also got Gomes, mind you. While Cespedes is a
better player, Gomes can post a high OPS (On-Base Plus Slugging). In fact, his
.771 OPS last year was 40 points better than Cespedes, and 10 points better
than Yoenis’ OPS this year.
Now they have arguably
four aces with Lester, Sonny Gray, Jeff Samardzija, and Scott Kazmir, with
Jason Hammel as the best 5th man in baseball. Billy Beane is going
all in this year, and clearly shows it with Lester. While Boston wins the
future battle, the Athletics strengthen their rotation even more, that they are
clear favorites to win the pennant.
Detroit Tigers: A
Why is Beane going all
in, getting more than enough? Honestly, I think part of the reason is because
he is afraid of the Tigers. It seems like every year Detroit shuts down
Oakland, and Justin Verlander pitches another miraculous Game 5 or Game 7. But with Lester and Samardzija, it seemed like
he would easily overcome Detroit this year.
BUT THEN THEY GOT DAVID
PRICE. Though I still think that Oakland will be the favorites, the Tigers pose
an even bigger threat to win not only this year, but next year as well. Now
they have Price until the end of 2015, and they didn’t even need to give up
much for it.
The deal sends Price to
the Tigers, OF Austin Jackson to the Mariners, and Drew Smyly, SS Nick
Franklin, and SS prospect Willy Adames to Tampa Bay. Adames, 18, is now ranked
as the 2nd best Rays’ prospect, according to MLB.com.
Jackson, 27, is hitting
.270/.330/.397 with a 99 OPS+ (adjusted
for ballpark factors), and has been the starting centerfielder for Detroit for
the last couple of years. Smyly, 25, has been both a starter and reliever in
three years as a big leaguer, and has put up a 3.77 ERA this year. Nick
Franklin, 23, is one of the best shortstops defensively, but needs to make
improvement on his hitting.
Overall, however, they
got a former Cy Young winner who only 28 years old and has been on fire in
July. Not only that, but they really didn’t give up any HUGE talent. Jackson
will be missed, but Price will make them, once again, a dangerous team to play
against.
Tampa Bay Rays: C
I think moving David
Price was the overall best move, but I think they could have gotten more from
it, or at least wait until the offseason to try to trade him. For example, the
Dodgers, who were the favorites in getting Price according to sources, have
plenty of young and talented prospects to give up if they wanted to go after
him.
Drew Smyly, Nick
Franklin, and Willy Adames all will have future success, but I expected them to
get more out of the former Cy Young winner. You saw the Cubs get one of the
best prospects in Addison Russell, and the A’s traded for two pitchers that are
nowhere near as good as Price.
What IS good is that
these guys will be Rays for a while. Smyly cannot become a free agent until
2018, Franklin in 2019, and Adames will probably be there for a long time.
Who knows, maybe in a
few years these guys will all be all stars. General Manager Andrew Friedman
said that they wouldn’t trade Price unless there was an offer that would be a
no-brainer. But was this really a no brainer?
St. Louis Cardinals: B
Like the Red Sox, the
Cardinals made a ton of moves, but they now face the opportunity to clinch a
tough NL Central division. They added two pitchers – Justin Masterson from the
Indians and John Lackey from the Sox – for a couple of Major League Players and
a prospect.
I like the Justin
Masterson trade because they get a guy that definitely needs a change of
scenery. After going 14-10 with a 3.45 ERA last year, he has completely lost
everything this year. He’s now 4-6 with a 5.51 ERA and a 68 ERA+, which is one
of the worst among starting pitchers.
They gave up James
Ramsey for him, an outfielder who represented the Cardinals in the Futures Game
during the all-star break. Ramsey was batting .300/.389/.527 with 13 home runs
and 36 RBI’s in the Cardinals minor league system, and is ranked as Cleveland’s
5th best prospect.
As for the John Lackey
deal, they get a guy for a year and a half to act as a 2nd or 3rd
starter in the rotation. Lackey, 35, has had a history of knee problems, but
has proven to come up as one of the best starters in the postseason (he won one
last year and one as a rookie in 2002 with Anaheim). This year, Lackey went
11-7 with a 3.60 ERA and a 1.6 WAR.
Losing Craig and Kelly,
however, is going to be tough, especially mentally for the team. Both of them
were brought up by the Cardinals system, and have been there for such a long
time. Was it worth it to lose them to get John Lackey?
I’m saying no, but the
Cardinals need pitching. Michael Wacha is on the 60-Day DL, and Jaime Garcia’s
future status is uncertain. Removing Craig also helps the Cardinals play top prospect
Oscar Taveras, who is struggling a bit in the Majors.
The Cardinals made
moves that make sense for now and the future, but they did have to give up
plenty to get not a whole lot.
Here are the other
trades that happened over the past two days:
·
Asdrubal Cabrera (Indians) to Nationals
for infielder Zach Walters
·
Jarred Cosart (Astros) to Marlins in
6-player deal
·
Martin Prado (D-Backs) to Yankees for
Peter O’Brien
·
James Russell and Emilio Bonifacio
(Cubs) to Braves for Victor Caratini
·
Chris Denorfia (Padres) to Mariners for
Stephen Kohlscheen and Abraham Almonte
·
Tommy Milone (Athletics) to Twins for
Sam Fuld
·
Gerardo Parra (D-Backs) to Brewers for
Mitch Haniger and Anthony Banda.
Will we have as good of
a July 31st as that? I don’t think we will for a long time.
No comments:
Post a Comment